A For-loop and List Comprehension Are Fundamentally Different at Scope Level

“For-loops and list comprehensions work the same way and do the same thing.”

This is a statement that I see in almost every Python introductory course/video/blog (or a differently phrased statement…I hope you get the idea).

But this is not entirely true.

Of course, purpose-wise, they do the exact same thing, and I am not denying it.

But what most Python programmers don’t know is that there’s a pretty fine difference between how a list comprehension and a for-loop operate internally at a scope level, and it’s something that every Python programmer must know.

Today, I want to share that with you.

Let’s begin!

Consider this simple for-loop code:

After running this for-loop, if we try to access the loop variable (loop_var), we notice that the variable is still accessible, as depicted below:

All good so far.

Now, let’s do this with a list comprehension instead. The following code is the list comprehension equivalent of the above for-loop:

After running this list comprehension, if we try to access the loop variable (loop_var), we notice that the variable is NOT accessible:

Strange, right?

Why is the loop variable accessible when we use a for-loop but not when we use a list comprehension?

This brings us to an essential difference between how for-loop and list comprehension fundamentally work, and it’s something I don’t find most Python tutorials talking about.

When we use a for-loop, Python leaks the loop variable into the surrounding scope. In other words, we can still access the loop variable once the loop is over.

But a list comprehension does not work this way. Thus, the loop variable always remains local to the list comprehension, and it is never leaked outside.

Also, if we use a pre-existing variable as our loop variable, for-loop will update its value while list comprehension will leave it unchanged.

This can be verified from the image below:

The value of the existing variable (loop_var):

• gets updated when used in a for-loop.

• remains unchanged when used in a list comprehension.

List comprehension does not update the value because, as discussed above, it creates a local copy of the loop variable.

This discussion is closely linked to the concept of ‘scope’ in Python, which can be of four types and is a critical topic in Python. I intend to cover that in an upcoming issue.

👉 Until then, it’s over to you: What are some other Python technical concepts that most programmers misinterpret?

👉 If you liked this post, don’t forget to leave a like ❤️. It helps more people discover this newsletter on Substack and tells me that you appreciate reading these daily insights.

The button is located towards the bottom of this email.

Thanks for reading!

Latest full articles

If you’re not a full subscriber, here’s what you missed last month:

• DBSCAN++: The Faster and Scalable Alternative to DBSCAN Clustering

• Federated Learning: A Critical Step Towards Privacy-Preserving Machine Learning

• You Cannot Build Large Data Projects Until You Learn Data Version Control!

• Sklearn Models are Not Deployment Friendly! Supercharge Them With Tensor Computations.

• Deploy, Version Control, and Manage ML Models Right From Your Jupyter Notebook with Modelbit

• Gaussian Mixture Models (GMMs): The Flexible Twin of KMeans.

• Bayesian Optimization for Hyperparameter Tuning.

To receive all full articles and support the Daily Dose of Data Science, consider subscribing:

👉 Tell the world what makes this newsletter special for you by leaving a review here :)

👉 If you love reading this newsletter, feel free to share it with friends!